GOUVERNEUR — After nearly a week of mourning, memorializing and mobilizing, roughly 200 people rallied for justice again Saturday. And the Gouverneur community doesn’t plan on slowing down.

“You give me the strength to go on, thank you,” Cedric Summerville told the group in the park after returning from a nearly 2-mile silent march around the village. “And I’ve got more family coming. We’re coming.”

Mr. Summerville, the biological father of 18-year-old Treyanna Summerville, who was found dead inside her Rowley Street home Monday, traveled from the Seattle area to be in Gouverneur this weekend. Mr. Summerville said his daughter, who has not lived with him since she was a younger child, had a good heart.

“This doesn’t make any sense,” he said.


With tears in his eyes, Cedric Summerville, Treyanna Summerville’s biological father, right, hugs a rally attendee Saturday afternoon in Gouverneur. A rally was organized in Ms. Summerville’s honor. She was found dead in her Gouverneur home Monday morning. Sydney Schaefer/Watertown Daily Times

Describing the controlling nature of Lashanna Charlton, Ms. Summerville’s biological mother who lived at 135 Rowley St. with Ms. Summerville and her 13-year-old sister, Mr. Summerville said Mrs. Charlton knew how to “coach” her daughters and believes she had control over the girls’ social media accounts.

“I’m not leaving here until she is locked up. I can’t,” Mr. Summerville said of Mrs. Charlton. “I can’t even mourn my daughter. ... We all know why Trey didn’t leave. She didn’t want to leave her sister. I can’t let that lie.”

Earlier this week, Ms. Summerville’s older stepbrother Isiah Samuels said he left 135 Rowley St. in 2015 after being physically and psychologically abused by Mrs. Charlton, his stepmother. He shared his experiences living in the house with Mrs. Charlton, Ms. Summerville and his now 13-year-old half sister charged with second-degree murder in connection to Ms. Summerville’s death. The homicide investigation is ongoing, and St. Lawrence County District Attorney Gary M. Pasqua on Friday afternoon said no additional information about the investigation is available at this time.

Mr. Samuels said he has been in contact with investigators this week about the case.

“She was just mad abusive for no reason,” Mr. Samuels said of his stepmother. “If we ate snacks without permission, she was mad. We couldn’t brush our teeth or shower without permission, we couldn’t have friends over, we couldn’t do anything.”


Isiah Samuels, Treyanna Summerville’s older stepbrother, center, speaks during a rally in her honor Saturday afternoon in the village. Ms. Summerville was found dead in her Gouverneur home Monday morning. Sydney Schaefer/Watertown Daily Times

All week, Mr. Samuels has steadfastly maintained his 13-year-old half sister’s innocence, saying she did not kill Ms. Summerville.

“There’s just no way,” he said, adding that his sisters “always got along” and would often dance together in Ms. Summerville’s room.

Born in Alaska, according to Mr. Samuels, Ms. Summerville loved the cool weather and Alaskan landscape. Next moving to Georgia, the family — Mrs. Charlton, her husband Rhodney A. Charlton, Ms. Summerville, Mr. Samuels and their younger half sister — moved to the north country in 2011. They lived together at 135 Rowley St., though Mr. Samuels said his father, Mr. Charlton, is a member of the U.S. Military and often traveled for training and was deployed out of the area several times.

Gouverneur tax records indicate Mr. Charlton has owned the house at 135 Rowley St. since 2012.

After receiving a phone call from Mr. Charlton, who indicated something was going on at the Rowley Street house Sunday, Mr. Samuels called his family in Gouverneur. When Mr. Samuels spoke to his 13-year-old sister, he said she sounded like she was “reading from a script.”

While Mr. Samuels was still living at the house, he engaged in typical sibling banter with Ms. Summerville, who he said had a fervent love for her hair and various hairstyles, listening to music and a love of cheese. She would tip-toe to the fridge to eat chilled slices, Mr. Samuels said.


Cedric Summerville, Treyanna Summerville’s biological father, holds a small plaque for his daughter high above his head during a rally in the Gouverneur village park in honor of Ms. Summerville on Saturday. Ms. Summerville was found dead in her home Monday morning. Sydney Schaefer/Watertown Daily Times

“Her superpower was turning anything into a toy,” Mr. Samuels said of Ms. Summerville’s innovation as a young child, playing with random objects around the house. “She just had a lot of potential.”

Jennifer Baxtron, of the Potsdam-based Black Lives Matter North Country Organizing Collective, organized a table of cheesecakes and a cooler of water set up in the park following the march.

Gouverneur’s Sunflour Cafe and Bakery generated about $600 on Friday, after selling mini cheesecakes decorated with blue icing for child abuse awareness. The proceeds, according to the bakery, will be donated to a school scholarship fund created by Ms. Summerville’s friends in her memory.

Gouverneur community organizers designed -JusticeForTrey T-shirts this week, with proceeds from T-shirt sales in the park going to Ms. Summerville’s funeral and scholarship fund. As of Saturday, organizers report $1,757 has been raised from T-shirt sales, with an additional $260 raised by Gouverneur students after the school’s Friday graduation. A Facebook fundraiser, established Wednesday, has generated $2,245 of a $5,000 goal to date. All proceeds are being transferred to Mr. Summerville and Mr. Samuels, according to the organizers on Facebook.

Beginning outside the Colonial Laundromats and Dashnaw’s Pizza, 174 E. Main St., the silent marchers walked west on Main Street toward Clinton Street and north to the Gouverneur Police Department, pausing there for five minutes. The marchers continued east on Trinity Street then southward to the village park. Along the route, cars honked in support of the demonstrators, a pair of men doing repair work outside a Clinton Street business offered water to the demonstrators and a woman waved from her yard, telling the group: “God bless you, and thank you.”


Isiah Samuels, Treyanna Summerville’s older stepbrother, holds a sign in front of the Gouverneur police station stating “They did nothing” in reference to how the police department handled his stepsister’s alleged abuse. Ms. Summerville was found dead inside her home Monday. Sydney Schaefer/Watertown Daily Times

A lone counterdemonstrator stood outside the Gouverneur Police Department holding a sign that read: “Sick of your ignorance.” He also wore a T-shirt, which read: “Hello? Don’t all lives matter WTF?”

Prior to departing from the laundromat, organizer John Youngblood, an associate professor at SUNY Potsdam, encouraged participants not to acknowledge any counterdemonstrators or people shouting at the group.

“We are not responding,” Mr. Youngblood said. “This might be the most difficult thing you’ve ever done. If you talk as much as I do, it’s definitely the most difficult thing you’ve ever done. It will be challenging, but we are going to honor Treyanna’s life and her death in silence.”

Ms. Baxtron said she knew some in the Gouverneur community on social media had expressed concern over the rally’s affiliation with the Black Lives Matter movement.

“People in the town thought because Black Lives Matter organized it that we were coming in to burn their town down and cause a ruckus,” she said, adding that the silent demonstration was a conscious decision. “Having a quiet one is more powerful. Let the words on the signs speak. ... No matter where it’s at, kids are getting lost to the system, killed by the system, and not getting what they need. I’ve been there.”

The demonstration was largely organized by BLM North Country Organizing Collective in collaboration with Mr. Samuels and community members. The group plans to continue rallying this week, with a demonstration scheduled for 11:30 a.m. Wednesday outside the St. Lawrence County Department of Social Services in Canton.

About 200 demonstrators walk down West Main Street in Gouverneur on their way through the village during a silent march Saturday in honor of Treyanna Summerville, the Gouverneur teen found dead in her home Monday morning. Sydney Schaefer/Watertown Daily Times

Mr. Samuels said his stepsister’s death represents a broader systemic problem with law enforcement and county Child Protective Services, a DSS department.

“It doesn’t start or end with Treyanna,” he said.

Ms. Baxtron, a Potsdam resident who has been a longtime community organizer in the area, said she reached out to the Gouverneur Police Department this week to let officers know the silent march and rally would be happening, as she always does prior to organized gatherings. She invited officers to participate and said she invited Gouverneur Police Chief Laurina Greenhill to the event.

No officers, at least identifiable by uniform, participated in the march, though patrol cars assisted with traffic direction and ushered the marchers safely along the route. Based on observation, Chief Greenhill was not present.

Calls and emails to the Gouverneur Police Department this week have not been returned. Gouverneur Central School District has also not returned phone or email messages or a Facebook message left this week.

Gouverneur village Mayor Ron McDougall participated in the demonstration with his wife. Addressing the group in the park, he expressed his heartbreak over Ms. Summerville’s death, describing his observations of the teen over the years. A nearby resident of 135 Rowley St., Mr. McDougall said he often saw Ms. Summerville walking in her community, feeling comfortable enough to greet him with a “hello” after some time.

Mr. McDougall called for “peace and justice for everyone.”

“And let’s not rest until we get it,” he said.


Cedric Summerville, Treyanna Summerville’s biological father, second from left, stands with Emily Burgess, a friend of Ms. Summerville’s, during a rally in the Gouverneur village park in honor of Ms. Summerville on Saturday. Ms. Summerville was found dead in her home Monday morning. Sydney Schaefer/Watertown Daily Times

The Rev. Katrina Hebb, of Potsdam First Presbyterian Church, offered a prayer near the close of Saturday’s park gathering, calling for protection, for healing and that “the truth would come to light.”

“Not for the purpose of vengeance,” she said. “But for the purpose of making a better way.”

Johnson Newspapers 7.1

Recommended for you

(10) comments


The headline should read

Gouverneur community goes about its life and doesn't wants answers

Because we don't care

Holmes -- the real one

You have already demonstrated just what you are made of -- most recently here: https://www.nny360.com/news/stlawrencecounty/justice-for-trey-classmates-reflect-on-gradual-decline-of-gouverneur-teen-found-dead-this-week/article_49ae6fd9-59b7-51cb-afdd-e9e865077c2f.html

It is quite clear that you don't care.

Thankfully, you do not represent the majority of residents of Gouverneur.

Skye Opel

I do not know the length of training to be a Gouverneur police officer. I am certain that it does not include sufficient training to be able to evaluate mental illness or physical trauma. Medical people should have answered this call. The outcome may have ended differently. That's just one of the reason we need to "defund" the police.


Really, defund the police and replace with what? Yea thats what we thought, you don't have an answer do you. When the next druggie assaults you, don't call the defunded police.


An unconscienable tragedy that could have been avoided had the authorities appointed to protect the public been awake and on the job. Instead, a shameful dereliction of duty transpired and a young woman is dead. SHAME!

Holmes -- the real one

Well said, Newsjunkie39a.

There are so many aspects of this situation that are really horrifying.

As reported here: ( https://www.nny360.com/news/crime/questions-abound-after-gouverneur-teen-s-death/article_daea2596-3165-57e6-837a-0f924cb4a621.html ) an incident is described which involved a police officer.

Finding a young girl sleeping inside a laundromat -- with a bloodied face and a cut on her head -- the police officer who was summoned summarily dismissed the situation suggesting that Treyanna had mental issues, that "she's known for walking around town and digging at her face to make it bleed like that. She digs at her scars.”

The resident who called initially called police tried to explain the concern to him: "“I explained to him, that’s not just a little scratch, her face looks tortured,” Ms. Serviss said. “The pictures you see online, and on Facebook, that wasn’t her face when I saw it. She had no hair on her head. It was shaved-looking.”

We are still awaiting an answer to the FOIL request regarding this police incident, but it seems clear already that this is not the way the matter would have been handled if she was a white girl.

Gouverneur -- this is on all of you. Indeed it is on all of us here in the North County. To the extent that we allow or tolerate racist thinking/speech/behavior as well as double standards we tacitly allow these kinds of situations to persist.

The actions of the police officer, Jason Whitton, need to be fully and openly investigated.

And we all, ALL OF US, need to search our deepest selves. This is a time to act and make a meaningful change.


No dude, this is not on us. She was 18, an adult, you cannot force her to do anything short of arresting her and for what. The system worked the way it was supposed to, it was her sister who killed her.


Really, since she was over 18, it was her choice, you can't force her. Most of the news stories are full of lies and more lies like her brother is spouting off.


Really, you have personal knowledge of lies? You should report that to someone.

Holmes -- the real one

knowledge, prior or otherwise, is probably something that "milocat" is not privy to. Prejudice however, is something that milocat" has in abundance. Take a look at the heartless comment here:


Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.