JULIE ABBASS/WATERTOWN DAILY TIMESLewis County Sheriff Michael Carpinelli addresses the county General Services Legislative Committee Tuesday night.

LOWVILLE — A controversy emerged at a Lewis County legislative committee meeting on Tuesday evening when Sheriff Michael Carpinelli made an unscheduled appearance to protest oversight of his spending — which has outpaced, and in some cases surpassed, the amounts allocated for the year.

Sheriff Carpinelli approached the committee to ask if the board stands behind the statement made in a letter from County Manager Ryan Piche informing him that he will not be able to purchase items that fall in the discretionary spending category of his budget until it’s clear he won’t need that money to cover overtime through the end of the year.

The sheriff read from the letter, which said it was meant to “make crystal clear that the board of legislators does not allocate additional funds at the year end to cover these (budget) gaps.”

He asked the General Services Committee, “Is that how you feel?”

With about half of the fiscal year completed, Mr. Piche said the Sheriff’s Department has used 81 percent of the funds budgeted for overtime pay for patrol deputies, or $32,385 of the $40,000 budgeted, and 210 percent of the overtime allocated for corrections officers at the county jail, $52,641 of the $25,000 budgeted.

A discussion ensued in which committee members and Mr. Piche said that because the Sheriff’s Department significantly overspent its budget last year, they could see things heading in the same direction and wanted to ensure they did not have to find money to compensate again.

Mr. Carpinelli was told he would have to find the money in his overall budget to cover overtime for the rest of the year.

“I can’t find it in my budget. There’s nothing there,” Mr. Carpinelli said, “For the past eight years of being sheriff, I’ve been kept to a minimal budget. I know some of you are going to disagree with that because some of you fail to listen and understand what it takes to run a secure facility in a professional manner — what it takes to run a safe community in Lewis County.”

The amount Mr. Carpinelli had first requested in the budgeting process for 2019, $3,239,818, had included an increase of nearly 10 percent over the 2018 budget. He said that if he had been granted the full amount, officials wouldn’t be going over budget on overtime.

“A 9.7 percent increase in a 2 percent tax cap environment is just not feasible,” Mr. Piche said.

The Sheriff’s Office was given a 7.5 percent increase in 2019 over the 2018 budget, from $4.9 million to $5.3 million, a larger bump than any other department, Mr. Piche said.

Although the sheriff’s budget was $177,914 less than he requested for the year, the amount he had budgeted for patrol overtime, $40,000, was not diminished, according to the 2019 budget document.

There was a drop from about $50,000 for the jail guard overtime line to $25,000; however, Mr. Piche said four guard positions were added into the budget, which should have cut the overtime hours needed.

Sheriff Carpinelli said the money has already been allocated for his discretionary spending account, and as an elected official, he should be able to use it as he sees fit.

“Yes, it’s been approved, but if you’re going over in other parts of your budget, that money has to come from somewhere,” said committee member Thomas Osborne, the District 9 legislator. “So hold off on buying anything unless it’s absolutely necessary. I don’t want to micromanage anybody. If there’s still money in the budget at the end, go ahead and get what you wanted, no questions asked.”

Other committee members agreed: the full $3.08 million budget has been allocated for the sheriff to manage and use as he sees fit, but when it’s gone, it’s gone, they said.

Last year, the Sheriff’s Office was over budget by about $175,000, not including expenses that couldn’t have been foreseen, for example medical evacuation and other medical costs for prisoners, according to Mr. Piche.

No clear information has been provided as to why so much overtime has been needed so far this year and that information has not yet been officially requested of the sheriff by the board. Committee members said they hope the sheriff will understand why they’ve felt the need to take action and curtail unnecessary spending: they don’t want a repeat of last year.

“We want to work with him,” said committee Chairman Jerry King, District 10 legislator. “I just hope he finds a way to stay in his budget because we just can’t afford these overruns.”

Johnson Newspapers 7.1

Recommended for you

(3) comments

A Dodger

Lewis County needs a new Sheriff. The county has budget workshops before the Going a half million dollars, five hundred thousand dollars over budget shows a lack of fiscal responsibility and overall poor management skills. How much will it cost taxpayers for Carp to go to the Sheriffs Showdown next month at the Hemlock Fair ? It takes a lot more than just your craft to be a department head and this one is not doing justice to the taxpayers by going that far over budget. I wonder how much forfeiture money the department gets and if they are working hard enough to create more of those funds so it doesn't strap the hard working people of Lewis County.


if Carpinelli wants to save money then have his deputies do something besides camp out at all the local businesses that give out free coffee? I have never seen a job where employees are allowed to take a break at the very beginning of their shift like LCS does everyday? They also have one deputy who lives in Constableville that goes to Lowville to pick up her car and then drive back home and park it in her garage instead of doing her job, and Carpinelli knows full well she does this. For what little some of these deputies do he can afford to eliminate some positions? There will never be enough money for him. You give him what he wants this year and he will want another 10% next year. If he can’t do the job, then he needs to retire and let someone else who can do it.


Carpinelli has gotten too big for his baby britches. Just because you send in a request for more money doesn't mean you can outspend what you're allocated. time for him to put his big boy britches on.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.