President Donald Trump greets U.S. Rep. Elise Stefanik on stage during an event in August 2018 at Fort Drum. Sydney Schaefer/Watertown Daily Times

TULSA, Okla. — President Donald Trump’s first rally in months, intended as a triumphant return to the campaign trail after the coronavirus forced nationwide lockdowns, began with a fizzle on Saturday night as the enormous crowds he anticipated in Tulsa failed to materialize.

Although some hardcore supporters camped out for days for a spot, there were empty seats throughout the upper decks of the downtown arena when Trump took the stage.

“We begin! We begin our campaign,” Trump said at the beginning of his speech. He called the crowd “warriors” for defying the “fake news” to attend his rally.

The Trump campaign tried to boost turnout at the last minute, sending out a text message saying “there’s still space,” but to no avail.

Trump also canceled an earlier speech at an outdoor event where there was supposed to be an overflow crowd of thousands. Instead, there were only a few dozen, and workers began dismantling the expensive stage around the time the president landed in Tulsa.

Tim Murtaugh, a campaign spokesman, claimed that “protesters interfered with supporters, even blocking access to the metal detectors.” But police on site said the entrance was blocked only briefly and no one was denied entry.

The sagging turnout in the deep-red state of Oklahoma may be a red flag for Trump’s reelection campaign, which is trailing by nearly double digits to Joe Biden, the presumptive Democratic nominee.

It’s also a blow to a president who counts on the adulation from faithful crowds. Trump has been eager to start holding rallies again after months of being cooped up in the White House as the coronavirus made public gatherings unsafe. Before Saturday, he had promised a “wild night.”

But there was relief in some corners of Tulsa that more people didn’t show up. Public health officials have feared that a tightly packed arena would supercharge the spread of the virus, especially with many of Trump’s supporters downplaying the threat of the pandemic and declining to wear masks.

There were also hopes that the city would be spared the violence that some feared as protesters and Trump supporters descended on downtown.

There was still some tension outside the arena, especially as police in riot gear stood by as two men — one Black and one white — began fighting.

Earlier, about 30 protesters approached a security gate at the edge of the arena’s outdoor rally area, chanting slogans popular with the left-wing movement known as antifa and carrying anti-Trump signs and a banner that said, “Revolution Nothing Less.”

They were surrounded by a group of Trump supporters, who recorded them on cellphones and chanted “USA!”

Trump risks inflaming racial tensions with his rally at a time when protests have swept across the country over the killing last month by a white Minneapolis police officer of George Floyd, an unarmed Black man.

Tulsa was the site of a race massacre in 1921, and Black community leaders have called Trump’s visit an insensitive provocation, especially because it falls on the weekend of Juneteenth, an annual commemoration of the end of slavery.

Across town from the arena, in the historically Black Greenwood district, the site of the 1921 massacre, activists covered memorials and murals ahead of an expected visit by Vice President Mike Pence.

“We don’t want him using our monuments for a photo op,” said Tyrance Billingsley III, 24, a local entrepreneur. He said the Trump administration was not welcome and is “100% diametrically opposed to what Greenwood stands for.”

Tykebrean “Ty” Cheshire organized a Rally Against Hate on Saturday evening and said she is expecting more than a thousand people, based on Facebook RSVPs. The rally is being staged at a park on the other side of the city to avoid conflict with Trump supporters.

“We’ve just got to keep it peaceful and not stress out,” Cheshire said, noting that she had heard from police that white supremacist groups were in town, including the Ku Klux Klan, Proud Boys and followers of the “boogaloo” movement.

“Hopefully they just want to listen to their man speak today and they won’t target us,” Cheshire said, noting that organizers had nevertheless planned a quick exit route from the park in case of trouble.

Trump has appeared untroubled and even energized by the prospect of chaos in the streets, a scene that could bolster his calls for “law and order.”

“Any protesters, anarchists, agitators, looters or lowlifes who are going to Oklahoma please understand, you will not be treated like you have been in New York, Seattle, or Minneapolis,” Trump tweeted Friday. “It will be a much different scene!”

Crowds gathered Saturday morning at the arena’s entrance gate, including Don Engle, the treasurer of neighboring Creek County.

“We’re real excited,” Engle said as he queued with his wife near the gate, where they had waited on and off for days. “I don’t think there’s any controversy at all. He’s picked us because we were the best at opening back up. That’s why we got this honor — that’s what it is, it’s not a problem, it’s an honor.”

Some said they were worried about COVID-19 and brought masks, which were also being sold outside the rally, along with face shields and hand sanitizer. But most said they did not intend to wear masks inside unless it was required.

“It was important to me to support what I believe in. I’m not going to let a bunch of people tell me I can’t do something. We’re still in a free country,” said Janet Arnold, 64, a massage therapist who drove to the rally from Bolivar, Mo., and described herself as “a gun-toting grandma.”

Oklahoma was among the first states to reopen in April and has remained open even as COVID-19 cases have increased dramatically in recent weeks.

On Saturday, Trump’s campaign said six staff members helping set up for his rally had tested positive for the coronavirus.

It’s been more than three months since Trump’s last rally. He’s returning to the campaign trail after a cascade of setbacks in recent weeks, including Supreme Court decisions overturning his administration’s policies and the pending release of a searing book by John Bolton, his former national security adviser.

Trump became involved in a new controversy Friday night when Attorney General William Barr announced that Geoffrey Berman, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York who has led investigations of Trump’s allies, was resigning. But Berman said he would not step down until the Senate approved a permanent replacement, creating a standoff over one of the most powerful posts in the Justice Department.

Coronavirus cases are also rising again in many parts of the country, raising the prospect of another surge in deaths and a return to the kinds of lockdowns that have forced tens of millions out of work.

Trump trails Biden, the former vice president and presumptive Democratic nominee, by nearly 9 percentage points in an average of polls compiled by Real Clear Politics.

“My campaign hasn’t started yet. It starts on Saturday night in Oklahoma!” Trump tweeted Friday.

Local public health officials urged Trump to cancel the rally, which creates a confluence of risk factors for contracting the disease — extended periods of time indoors and people chanting or cheering in close proximity to one another.

“I know so many people are over COVID, but COVID is not over,” said Bruce Dart, executive director of the Tulsa Health Department.

The president’s campaign had attendees sign a waiver pledging not to sue if they get sick from the event.

Tribune Wire

Recommended for you

(34) comments

keyser soze

Maybe for the Dotard’s next act… err, I mean rally, Elise can be tasked with blowing up inflatable MAGA dolls for the empty seats.

With all that foul wind she’s been expelling of late she is perfect for the job.

Just hook her up with a nozzle and your ready to go.

Holmes can hold the nozzle.



Comrade stefanik was spotted driving Agolf Twitlers golf cart today trying to destress her DADDy

hermit thrush


Acyn Torabi

Compilation of people bragging about a million people signing up for the rally


keyser soze

Hahaha… only 6,200 slack jawed MAGAbillies turned up to the arena when it can fit nearly 19,000!!

It probably would have been easier to rent canned laughter and applause tracks to fill in the void.

So sad.

keyser soze

Terrible show, dreadful ratings, and a poor performance only a Dotard could give. If the Failure in Chief’s presidency was a television program it would have been canceled by now.

All the more reason for the American people to terminate him and his corrupt regime on Nov. 3.

Rating: 0

hermit thrush

to be honest we should all be applauding the trump campaign for holding a properly socially distanced rally. if restaurants are only allowed to fill up to 50% capacity, why should a campaign event at a stadium be any different?




Hmmm, but you can riot, I mean protest without any concern??

hermit thrush

what on earth are you babbling about now? i mean, "but you can teargas peaceful protesters and priests in a church without any concern?" is that you want us to rewrite it?


That's what right-wing whack jobs have been saying for years, HoMe.

Remember Charlotteville?

Holmes -- the real one

Yeah, we sure can imagine Biden speaking. Coherently. For four years. Can hardly wait.

Hilarious -- you talking about "in their right mind."


The ramp wins again.








Can you imagine Sleepy Joe speaking for 1 hour and 44 minutes? Without notes? and coherent? With a message? Joe can't go a minute without a mental lapse. No one in their right mind can consider Joe Biden as president. Go Trump!


That is precious, using coherency as a plus for tRUMP.


Homey if you get a divorce is she still considered your sister?

keyser soze

Like an aged comedian way past his prime, repeating the same old stale routine full of empty rhetoric and grandiose BS. Cult like fans like Fake Holmes laugh where they know they're supposed to laugh; but it's forced. They slowly file out lying to themselves about how great it was, but knowing the fake magic is gone, the Dotard is naked… and it ain’t a pretty sight. [beam][tongue]


Homey hiding this morning,the end of the government of putin,* hows, that tooth doing?


you see holmes,toothless,, with all his inbred relatives,so funny,losers


Tulsa fire department had attendance at 6300.stefanik must have given Agolf Twitter and nice lap dance on the way back to dc,DC, a bunch of losers




I don't know what rally the author attended, but Trump's rally had a huge crowd, The only empty seats were those allegedly reserved by Democrat operatives trying to negatively impact the rally. The Democrats know they are in trouble and that is obvious.

Holmes -- the real one


The biggest crowd in the history of our country. No other president could have done it. The generals were all amazed.

And the crowd cheered when he drank water using only one hand!!

Holmes -- the real one

And also from Ben G:

"We are extremely fortunate that Donald Trump is our President during this time of crisis. I can't imagine having one of those idiots from the left in charge." https://www.nny360.com/opinion/editorials/editorial-time-to-grow-up-trump-must-put-childish-antics-aside-during-health-care-crisis/article_c3d3fbdb-0c2f-537d-adc8-926f73adfa37.html


I agree and you are about the only sane person on this comment page. The rest are just plane ugly in there acceptance of the AP article which is not the real story.




Biden was able to hold a glass of water in one hand, he just didn’t know what to do with it.


POTUS "over one million people wanted to go.....over 900,000...record setting crowd...never an empty seat".... If his response is Democrats reserved the seats inside...and the facility holds 22,000, there should be at least 800,000 plus outside.. . duh? Can you explain that ?? I'll wait...take your time... or just tune into Fox, they'll have some BS answer you'll drink like cool aid...use that...




[beam] It's gotta be extremely painful being that ignorant[beam]

hermit thrush

a tulsa fire department spokesperson said they counted a hair under 6,200 attendees, out of a capacity of 19,200.



keyser soze

Many people say.[sleep]

Holmes -- the real one

Yuuuuge.Thanks sharpie.


Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.