City Manager: ISO fire rating expected to remain same despite staff cuts, claims

The Ogdensburg Fire Department, 718 Ford St. Matt Curatolo/The Journal

OGDENSBURG — The city’s Insurance Services Office fire rating is expected to remain the same, despite cuts to staffing at the fire department and claims by people who Ogdensburg City Manager and Fire Chief Stephen P. Jellie calls “local government disruptors.”

Mr. Jellie, in a press release issued Wednesday, said that the city completed its ISO fire rating visit on Tuesday as part of a five-year evaluation. An ISO fire rating is a score provided to fire departments and insurance companies by the ISO. The score reflects how prepared a community is for fires — 1 being the most prepared and 10 being the least prepared. The city’s current rating is a 4, obtained in 2016.

“The initial review of information presented to the evaluator does not demonstrate that the city will have a decrease in its rating, and likely not have an increase. The rating will be issued in the next several weeks and be available for public review,” Mr. Jellie said in his prepared statement.

He said that a complete and comprehensive report will be provided and available to all for review as soon as it is issued by ISO.

Beginning in 2022, the fire department will set a goal of improving to a Class 3 rating, according to Mr. Jellie.

“The standard to increase above a 4 is very rigid and will require a commitment to quality improvement and preparedness. As discussed at the city council meeting last evening (Monday), staffing has very little to do with the overall rating and the recent changes to staffing at OFD will not reduce the current rating and nor will an increase in staffing improve it,” the press release stated.

In a portion of the press release that Mr. Jellie labeled as “Facts,” he wrote that “residents are not in any increased danger, property is not at risk and insurance rates will not increase.”

“Factually, many of the nation’s largest insurance carriers do not use the ISO rating any longer as a gauge of risk so the ISO rating means nothing to households with carriers like State Farm and Allstate,” Mr. Jellie wrote.

He added that the fire department is operating in a “highly efficient manner,” is “well trained, well prepared and ready to respond,” and that it now costs far less than in previous years to provide fire protection to city residents. It is one of the ways the City Council was able to reduce the tax rate by 10% in 2021 and possibly in 2022, as proposed in the preliminary budget.

The 2022 preliminary budget calls for a reduction of three members of the fire department to 18 employees. The proposal will have a fire chief, one assistant chief, four captains and 12 firefighters.

Mr. Jellie’s release indicated “life safety” is the No. 1 priority.

He called out a small group of residents — he calls “local government disruptors” — who are using the ISO rating as their “latest attempt to elicit fear and anxiety in the community.” Some have stated on social media that the ISO rating will worsen with the cuts to the fire department and insurance rates will increase.

“Please do not pay any attention to their fictional tales and deliberately false information designed only to garner the personal attention they desperately seek,” wrote Mr. Jellie, “Their claims of increased risk to personal safety and negative impact on insurance rates is as false as their credibility.”

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Johnson Newspapers 7.1

Recommended for you

(1) comment


Maybe before you write these articles, you should do your research and look into the ISO rating. Mr. Jelly is incorrect, staffing levels directly affect their ratings.

What Is an ISO Rating? And Why It’s Important

How Can You Lower Your ISO Rating?

Due to your fire department’s commitment to public safety, you decided to get an ISO rating. However, you weren’t pleased with the score. You want a lower score next time. Is there anything you can do to improve your score?

Yes, actually! You have plenty of options, so let’s wrap up by talking about them.

Hire More Personnel

The ISO field representative counts how many personnel your fire department has at any one time. If you have a relatively small team now, it’s not a bad idea to hire more firefighters and then look into getting reevaluated by the ISO.

If your fire team is already quite sizable, then reconsider their schedules. The ISO field rep only counts the firefighters in the building during their evaluation, not the off-duty ones at home. By increasing the number of personnel in the fire department, your PPC score could be lower.

ISO Fire Suppression Rating Schedule Resources

Insurance Services Office

Fire Suppression Rating Schedule (FSRS) Overview

How your community can improve its ISO rating

Fire department (50 points): Many parts of the fire department score will be difficult for a community to improve on, such as the number of on-site staff and distance between emergency services and houses. However, improvements in the fire department category can be made in several more feasible (though still expensive) ways, such as:

According to ISO's Fire Suppression Rating Schedule (FSRS), four main criteria comprise a fire rating score:

50% comes from the quality of your local fire department, including staffing levels, training and proximity of the firehouse.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.