Health care workers aren’t the only ones with rights

Protesters gathered Sept. 8 outside of Samaritan Medical Center in Watertown to express their discontent with the state mandate for all health care workers to be vaccinated by Monday or lose their jobs. Provided photo

WATERTOWN — Of those who claim they have a valid reason for not being vaccinated against the novel coronavirus, health care employees have the weakest argument.

First of all, they work in the industry that has the best answers to concerns over the vaccines. This includes how effective the vaccinations have proven to be and their long-term effects on people. Staff members of medical facilities should know how to seek out the most current and soundest advice from experts and follow their guidelines.

Secondly, they undermine their own authority as representatives of the health care field. Every day, they ask people to trust them with their well-being. Why should we put our lives in the hands of those who lack confidence in the scientific authorities who lead their profession?

And finally, they put their patients at significant risk of becoming infected if they won’t get vaccinated. Many health care workers declare that they have the right to decide whether or not to become immunized. While this is true, they have no right to force others to live with the dreadful consequences of the dismal choices they make.

New York has ordered all health care workers to get at least one shot of the three available vaccinations by Monday or risk being terminated for cause. Of course, an exception will be made for individuals who have legitimate health issues preventing them from receiving the shots.

But that’s it. The state will deny exemptions made on religious grounds. And it certainly won’t tolerate health care employees who hesitate because of the numerous unfounded concerns many others have raised.

On Sept. 14, a federal judge called for a temporary restraining order on the state’s mandate. This resulted from a lawsuit filed by 17 New York health care employees through the Thomas More Society, a Chicago-based law firm. It’s not known yet whether this lawsuit will prevent the state from carrying out its vaccination order.

It’s unfortunate that it’s come to the point where state officials feel the need to compel medical staffers to be vaccinated. Substantial evidence shows that the vaccines are safe and effective against catching the virus and spreading it to others. It’s also the best protection from becoming seriously ill from COVID-19 in the rare case that infection occurs.

So it’s astonishing that so many health care workers won’t get vaccinated. What do they not understand about the alarming statistics showing infections, grave illness and death occurring mostly among those who have refused to get the shots? When will it finally sink in that they’re playing with fire when it comes to their health and the lives of the people they serve?

By not being vaccinated, they are about four times more likely to become infected, nine times more likely to be hospitalized with COVID-19 and 11 times more likely to die than are vaccinated individuals. Those are the stark facts of this pandemic.

And it’s gotten even worse with the delta variant. This mutation is much more transmissible than its predecessor.

In addition, mutations occur more rapidly as the virus spreads. Will we get to a point where the protections we have now are no longer effective?

The conclusion is crystal clear: Unvaccinated people are exacerbating this health care crisis! I know this sounds harsh, but it’s also the truth.

Various stories have been published over the past few weeks in the Watertown Daily Times about potential staff shortages at medical facilities due to New York’s mandate. Some state law legislators have criticized the administration of Gov. Kathy Hochul for moving ahead with this order.

Some health care workers have raised concerns about the long-term effects of the coronavirus vaccinations. Others don’t believe it’s ethical to benefit from something that has some connection to aborted fetuses.

The scientific consensus is that the vaccines won’t result in harmful side effects down the road. Unlike other medications shown years later to pose serious risks, vaccines usually reveal problems within weeks. And while there have been some side effects with the vaccines, most are minor.

Only three deaths have been documented to have occurred as a result of taking one of the vaccinations. This was with the Johnson & Johnson/Janssen vaccine earlier this year. Six women developed blood clots resulting in three fatalities, but no similar problems have been reported since a review was conducted and some changes made to the vaccine.

Public health authorities have found the vaccinations to be safe for pregnant women. And pro-life leaders, including Pope Francis, said that while some of the vaccines have a remote link to fetal cell lines, people should still be immunized given the seriousness of the pandemic.

People resisting being vaccinated against the coronavirus for ethical reasons should know that the vaccines for chickenpox, hepatitis A, measles, mumps, rabies and rubella have the same connection to fetal cell lines. And so do numerous over-the-counter medications such as Advil, Aleve, Benadryl, Claritin, Ex-Lax, Lipitor, Maalox, Motrin, Pepto Bismol, Preparation H, Prilosec, Senokot, Sudafed, Tums, Tylenol and Zoloft. If you sincerely object to one, you should oppose them all.

I appreciate how health care workers are wrestling with the many issues raised about the coronavirus vaccine. The position they find themselves in is troubling indeed.

But here are the facts they need to face:

They are much more likely to become infected if they don’t get vaccinated. This means they’ll endanger the lives of their patients; many of them are immunocompromised for various reasons. How can their employers allow them to come into contact with individuals given such grave risks?

The overwhelming conclusion of medical experts is that the vaccines are safe and offer the best protection against catching and spreading the virus. If you work in the health care industry, perhaps you should trust the judgment of the medical/scientific leaders in this area. They too have a stake in all of this and certainly aren’t going to put themselves and their loved ones in jeopardy with poor research or misleading statements.

The suggestion of having unvaccinated health care workers tested each week is no good. This will be an ongoing expense for months — and who’ll pay for it?

In addition, a test captures one moment in a whole week. The employee could become infected shortly after being tested and walk around for days spreading the virus to other people. Getting as many vaccinated as possible is the only sensible solution to halt this pandemic.

So I don’t know what other option the state has but to force the hand of health care workers who won’t listen to reason. Everyone who seeks treatment from medical professionals should feel confident that those serving them won’t imperil their lives with reckless behavior.

It’s time for the staff members of health care and nursing facilities to do the right thing and put their patients first. If they can’t do that, they should consider another line of work.

Jerry Moore is the editorial page editor for the Watertown Daily Times. Readers may call him at 315-661-2369 or send emails to They also may follow him on Twitter: @WDT_OpEd.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Johnson Newspapers 7.1

Recommended for you

(5) comments


I commend you for stating an opinion that’s sure to be unpopular with many upstaters. Spot on, tho.

The biggest problem humanity faces now is climate change and we can’t address that because of distractions. Taking the vaccine should be such an easy choice. I was so eager and felt so liberated after getting it that I can’t conceive of anyone fighting so hard against it. And all because it’s not what your “team” is supposed to believe.

And then there’s the petulant man-child still crying that the election was stolen from him. Why are we still having to argue over that when vast areas of the country burn and the Pacific NW hits 120 degrees? We’ve become a totally unserious species.

She's back

Those nurse and staff who are not vaccinated have already violated the rights of others. Covid has again been brought into at the Samaritan Keep home. While the staff are free to come and go shop and eat out and visit with their own families this right is denied to the Families of the Residents as visitation remains suspended until October fifth. And check out the "solitary confinement " requirements of any Resident who ventures out:

>>ANY resident going out of the facility other than for medical appointments and/or testing

will need to self-restrict (quarantine) to their room for 10 days if vaccinated or 14 days if

not vaccinated. The resident will not be able to participate in activities during this time.

Meals will be delivered to the room. COVID-19 testing will be done as per policy.

 Please consider putting off your visits, shopping or unnecessary outings for the next 4-6



When a "clear and present danger" exists government has every right to suspend an individual's most inalienable rights.

Mandatory vaccines for something a simple as buying a bag of groceries or pumping a gallon of gas, let alone treating hospital patience, . Enough of the lies & misinformation! Get the shot or go into solitary but get out of the way of our victory against COVID!

hermit thrush

great column, jerry.


Jerry nailed it... these people are the 21st century versions of Typhoid Mary....selfish doesn't begin to explain it... Recent article by a nurse trying to justify her non-vax position admitted she'd had Covid twice... how many had she infected... ??? Her level of safety protocol would certainly be questioned... Raise their insurance premiums and quit paying for their Covid tests...and put them in the back of the line in our ICU's... They're taking beds from those who don't self inflict their maladies..

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.