Lauding courage and independence in 2019

Rekha Basu

DES MOINES (Tribune News Service) — We opened 2019 with the federal government in shutdown over funding for a wall with Mexico.

We closed it with an impeachment and acts of terror against minorities:

A man who kept handwritten anti-Semitic screeds allegedly barged into a New York Hanukkah party and stabbed five people; a Des Moines woman tried to drive over a black boy and then a Latina girl telling authorities it was because she was “a Mexican.”

Scarcely a day went by in 2019 without reason for shock, anxiety or anger.

If not signs of hatred, or an extreme climate event, it was a divisive, unsettling political rant by tweet.

We open the 2020s at what feels like a turning point.

Fears are mounting over job losses in a future economy propelled by self-driving cars, self-checkout lanes and everything moving online.

Some corporate “downsizing” is already underway from mergers, as many in the news business know firsthand.

Stress morphs into blame, and distrust, insecurity and isolation trigger a palpable malaise.

“They’re scared,” observed former Vice President Joe Biden in a recent Register editorial board meeting about his presidential candidacy. “This fourth industrial revolution is real. Will there be a middle class?”

That fear has led fellow Democratic presidential hopeful Andrew Yang to propose a universal basic income of $1,000 a month to every working-age American.

Whether or not that’s a long-range solution, at least it’s an idea, and that’s the good news.

At a time when people are feeling little control over what happens, new ideas are emerging, some from the unlikeliest places, including people who stand to lose personally from them.

Consider a group of several hundred wealthy Americans in 34 states, who call themselves the Patriotic Millionaires.

They’ve been lobbying others of their status, along with elected officials, to raise taxes on the super wealthy and corporations.

In 2019 the group, which includes Disney heiress Abigail Disney, helped develop legislation inspired by Sen. Elizabeth Warren’s call for a 2 percent surtax on those with assets over $50 million — 3 percent on those above $1 billion.

In November, they introduced a bill to raise the estate tax.

In July, the House passed another bill they supported, to raise the federal hourly minimum wage to $15 by 2025.

Some jokingly quip that they are “class traitors,” but the impetus is the alarming concentration of wealth at the top.

A study referenced in a New Yorker story finds executive pay has jumped 940 percent since 1978, while worker pay has risen only 12 percent, leaving income inequality as extreme as in the 1920s.

Then there’s climate change and the fight against it led by a 16-year-old who is Time’s 2019 Person of the Year.

Greta Thunberg of Sweden, who has Asperger’s syndrome, had been worrying about climate change since age 8.

At one point she got so depressed, she stopped talking, eating, and going to school.

Then in May 2018, she wrote a climate-change essay that won a competition in a Swedish newspaper.

That prompted her to launch Fridays For Future, staging sit-ins outside the Swedish parliament and urging other students to skip school to demand action from their governments.

On Sept. 20, 2019, Thunberg led the largest climate strike in history, involving 4 million people in 161 countries.

She has addressed the United Nations, the U.S. Congress and the British Parliament, bluntly and tearfully telling the U.N., “You all come to us young people for hope? How dare you! You have stolen my dreams and my childhood with your empty words.”

She has credited her Asperger’s for her fearlessness.

Back in America, a new activism mushroomed over one of the world’s oldest standoffs:

The Israeli occupation of Palestine.

Jewish Voice for Peace, a 501(c)(4) organization that counts 170,000 U.S. supporters, formed JVP Action to lobby for human rights for Palestinians.

Its members are currently in Iowa to make a case to Democratic presidential candidates for conditioning aid to Israel on an end to human rights abuses against Palestinians.

A poll by the progressive Data for Progress finds the idea is supported by 65 percent of Democrats.

So far, Sen. Bernie Sanders is the only candidate to voice support for a major change in strategy.

“Palestinians, like everybody else, deserve freedom and human rights, and we are against the U.S. paying for injustice against Palestinians,” said Michael Deheeger, an organizer with JVP Action, by phone.

He said the Action wing was formed in August to support U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib of Michigan, who is Muslim and was denied a visa by Israel.

Some members were inspired by Black Lives Matter, he said.

Rabbi Alissa Wise, the co-acting executive director of Jewish Voice for Peace, recently responded to Trump’s claim that Jews who don’t unconditionally support Israel don’t love it enough.

“More and more American Jews are critical of Israel, disgusted by Trump’s enabling of white supremacy, and actively supporting presidential candidates who oppose anti-Semitism and racism,” she said.

Members of the Catholic clergy found the courage in 2019 to speak publicly against the handling of sexual abuses against seminarians and priests by the church’s chain of command.

On Aug. 15, Stephen Parisi, dean of his class in the Buffalo, N.Y., Catholic seminary, wrote to its bishop about a priest who took confession from a seminarian and then blackmailed him by demanding sex.

He also wrote of one who plied a seminarian with scotch, resulting in the latter’s DUI.

He wrote the seminary was being used as a “dumping ground” for problem priests with “troubling personal histories.”

Parisi and the academic chairman of the class alleged they faced bullying by superiors, interrogation by their academic dean and shunning by fellow seminarians for speaking out.

But they opened eyes.

In the face of so much that’s wrong, it’s heartening to see people push back and make a dent.

As always, the best antidote to despair is action.

Let’s make 2020 matter.

Rekha Basu is a columnist for the Des Moines Register. Readers may send emails to Distributed by Tribune Content Agency. © 2020 Des Moines Register.

Tribune Wire


Recommended for you

(1) comment


Ms. Basu's excellent piece references the sex abuse scandal at the seminary in Buffalo. She is referring to Christ the King Seminary in East Aurora, NY, located in the Diocese of Buffalo. Rumors and gossip about the culture at the Seminary have swirled nebulously for decades (not that they haven't at other seminaries as well). The tradition has been to cover it up. However, last August, Christ the King seminarian Stephen Parisi courageously wrote a 6-page letter, abruptly withdrawing himself from the Seminary and exposing in detail its corrupt culture. At the end of Parisi's letter, he lists a number of clerical figures. To them, his letter speaks. Among the clerical figures is Bishop Terry LaValley, Diocese of Ogdensburg. Why? Because, over the years, Bishop LaValley and his predecessors have placed innumerable seminarians from the Diocese of Ogdensburg at the Seminary. Presently, three of the Diocese's thirteen seminarians attend Christ the King. Heads up, Parisi's letter means to say, Christ the King Seminary is not a suitable place for priestly formation, indeed, it's more like a den of iniquity. How's that for provoking despair? In the face of despair, what actions has Bishop LaValley taken to ensure the well being of the three seminarians he sent to Christ the King? Has he removed them from the Seminary? Bishop LaValley, himself, is a graduate of the notorious Seminary. Might this influence his actions or lack thereof? Has he questioned the suitability of the various seminaries attended by the remaining ten seminarians? What actions have Catholics in the Diocese of Ogdensburg taken to ensure that Bishop LaValley acts on behalf of the well being of all seminarians?

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.