All of us benefit when freedom is expanded

Roland Van Deusen

“It is impossible to struggle for rights, equal rights for blacks, without including whites. Because equal rights, fair play, justice are like the air: We all have it, or none of us has it. That is the truth of it.”

— Maya Angelou

The president of the Syracuse NAACP has this quote on the end of all her emails. We north country folks have been whipsawed lately between a fourth-grade “slave auction,” an Atlantic magazine writer praising our “tolerance” and one local praying for a mass shooting at a Watertown Pride event.

TV news assaults us with drowned or imprisoned Latino children or a president blaming Puerto Ricans for dying because the hurricanes cut off electricity to their hospitals. I can’t be objective here, in part because I loved hearing my San Juan in-laws call me Rolando.

Maya Angelou is on to something as a kinder, gentler way to tackle at least one facet of intolerance: black/white relations. Her theme may be one key to getting enough blue collar white voters to see what’s in it for them to support equal justice and opportunity for all. My fellow north country residents may be able to relate to some of these ideas.

By way of background, my involvement in this area goes back more than a half century. In the spring of 1967, I was one of the student organizers of a civil rights demonstration at Syracuse University, covered by film crews for CBS, ABC and NBC (not sure if Joe Biden joined in, among the thousands of fellow students back then who took part).

During the summer of 1968, I volunteered for James Farmer, leader of the Freedom Rides, while home on leave from the U.S. Navy. Three others who volunteered for Farmer a few years earlier had been murdered in Mississippi.

Much more recently, I helped with research on a 19th century north country/Canada Underground Railroad activity (“location, location, location”) for the North Star Underground Railroad Museum.

Decades of interest in these areas led to the concepts below, praised in 1996 by Harvard’s Henry Louis Gates Jr. as having national applicability. The Syracuse NAACP last month called these ideas “inspirational.”

Some veterans magazines report fertile KKK recruiting grounds among disgruntled white veterans, especially in the South. The 1967-8 U.S. Navy I was in was racially segregated in overseas duty stations, job assignments and housing. Racial tensions in our military are a clear and present danger to our homeland security.

Losing trust with the citizens on their beat, police sabotage their best crime-fighting tool: accurate, timely word on the street from the locals. Military police work in four different countries taught me this much.

Our fragile economy drags behind and limps along for all of us, undercut by lack of equal opportunity, education, worker productivity and consumer spending power among millions of Americans, far too often of color. Then billions of self-perpetuating tax dollars go for welfare and criminal justice efforts to deal with those unfairly left behind. Institutional racism, therefore, gives the lower 98 percent a no-win economy.

The expansion of Fort Drum in the 1980s was a local example of the 1960s Green Power argument of the Civil Rights movement: We all benefit when equality happens — the economic pie growing because all slices are equal. North country tolerance efforts played a part. This could work elsewhere.

A lack of equal opportunity in the health professions drains the talent pool for workers of color. This leaves the whole population less equipped to be protected from the ravages of disease and injury.

Nationwide, non-Hispanic white Americans in kindergarten are the new minority. Does any white grandparent wish their grandchildren to be treated like their own grandparents might have treated others?

Many church-going white Americans insist we are a “Christian” nation. Do they truly believe they can fool their God by mouthing the “Our Father” while treating others as less than family?

I’m sure that the collective north country brain power can think of many more and much better “selling points” along these lines to help our fellow caucasian citizens see the light — or at least feel the heat.

Roland Van Deusen is a Clayton resident. He served in the U.S. Navy and is a retired counselor.

Johnson Newspapers 7.1


Recommended for you

(10) comments


In response to one little part. Whatever the Viet Nam era military was like, those who thrive in the professional, volunteer military are those who internalize the institutional values, which are completely in opposition to racism. Since everyone succeeds when the boss succeeds, mission is everything, and all else is subordinated to serving it. And divisive ethnic loyalties, other than American, do not contribute. Does this mean there are no racists? No, it just means they don't fit in, so they went back to where they were and did what they were going to do anyway, never having grown. Oh, a few hang in and live with an environment they hate, but they suffer for it and eventually it wears them down. Does this mean military people are all "woke"? Not at all, there's plenty of blind privilege and assumptions that there's no problem. But a secret right wing racist military conspiracy is not a thing. You'll find that somewhere else.


Memo to liberals: Not everything in the world has to do with race, but the left’s obsession with identity politics tries to make it so.

hermit thrush

memo to conservatives: not everything in the world has to do with race, but far more of it does than the right is willing to concede (or i guess is capable of observing).


You're generalizing about "the left." Yes, there's a movement trying to insert identity into everything, and it characterizes itself as "the left" but really it's a venn diagram situation. The set of lefties and the set of identity warriors overlaps but the sets are far from identical. Wiser and more successful leaders of "the left," including many of the current democratic presidential candidates, are primarily about government taking an active role in making society better and more fair for all. Feeling pressure from the agent provocateurs and disguised stooges screaming for all straight white men to get out of the Democratic party immediately because they don't belong, these candidates are all signing on to the litany of ideas coming from the gang of four, but it's not where their hearts are.

Holmes -- the real one

Memo to those who appropriate the name of another and then post nonsense: I'm sure it is clear to everyone where comments like that are coming from.


Memo to you, we aren't going to get "Justice for Garrett" due to the racism of local police and the racism of the voters who elected Mary Rain. We are going to pay millions of dollars in settlements due to their racist bungling of the case though. Repeating Rush Limbaugh makes you look like a fool.


I could only read half of this and started to gag. This is one persons junk mostly about themselves and much of it disputable. I too served in 1967-8 during the tet offensive and say no mistreatment of black soldiers. Blacks in America can and do just as well as all Americans, it is up to them, the opportunity is there but they got to go get it. Quit feeling sorry for them and it will help them a lot.

hermit thrush

your blindness to structural racism is the thing that should really make us all gag.


Although I may not have said it your way my gag reflux was coming out as well. Sigh...many words, no depth or real fact. I do like the Angelou quote though.


Sorry, Trump has told us that we don't need to respect veterans any more. RObert Mueller, John McCain, and John Kerry are just the start of the list of veterans our president has spat on. Keep your veteran status to yourself, and thank Republicans for making disrespecting veterans a thing!

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.