No right to harm other people

Andrey Popov/Dreamstime/Tribune News Service

The following editorial appeared in the Post-Star on June 20:

GLENS FALLS — A key constitutional concept that those opposed to vaccines don’t seem to appreciate is that rights have limits, and you don’t get to exercise your rights at the expense of someone else.

If, for example, your free exercise of religion involves human sacrifice, that isn’t protected by the First Amendment. Likewise, you don’t get to put other people’s babies at risk of contracting dangerous diseases because you want your kids to prance around unvaccinated.

New York has done the right thing in passing a law that eliminates religious exemptions from the requirement that schoolchildren be vaccinated. Exemptions for medical reasons, such as allergies and autoimmune diseases that make vaccines dangerous, will still be granted.

A good argument could be made that parents should not be allowed to endanger the health of their children by refusing to have them vaccinated. Just as parents are required by law to feed their kids something besides Twinkies and to buckle their seat belts, they could also be required to take the minimum steps to protect them from diseases.

But New York, like all the other states, isn’t going that far. Anti-vaxxers in New York can continue to risk the health and the lives of their own kids for no good reason if they choose.

What they will not be able to do, from now on, is to send their kids to public school, where diseases they may be carrying can be transmitted to other families.

One myth in this myth-heavy field is that anti-vaxxers aren’t putting anyone else — just themselves — at risk. But those folks who for medical reasons cannot get vaccinated will always be at risk of infection. Also, babies who haven’t received all their shots yet are at risk. Vaccinations get spaced out over the first year or two of a child’s life, and it’s easy to see how a baby could be infected in a public place like, for example, a pediatrician’s office.

Keeping unvaccinated kids out of public school doesn’t solve the problem, because children mingle in many public places, and it’s easy for unknowing transmission of childhood diseases to occur. Measles, for example, can live in the air for hours and is highly contagious. Also, it can be spread for days before and after symptoms are obvious.

But it’s very difficult to ban unvaccinated kids, or adults, from the grocery store or movie theater or park. It’s easy for schools to require the submission of vaccination records (they already do), and making vaccines mandatory for schoolkids should persuade most parents to be sensible.

The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled both that states can require vaccinations of citizens and that school districts can require them of students.

“There are manifold restraints to which each person is necessarily subject for the common good,” wrote Justice John Marshall Harlan on this issue in 1905.

That sums it up.

Out of foolishness and ignorance, anti-vaxxers risk the health of their own children. But by also risking other people’s health, they are acting against the common good, and states have the right to try to limit the damage they cause.

Johnson Newspapers 7.1


Recommended for you

(5) comments


Does this mean more home schooling? In some individuals I feel the diseases like mumps, measles, whooping cough and even scarlet fever, if caught by the child may give that child a stronger immune system making them much healthier through there lives. I had the diseases I quote and I have never been sick a day in my life. Get vaccinated don't listen to me.


Your science is as good as your politics. Getting Chickenpox as a kid is what gives you Shingles as an adult. Ever know anybody with Shingles? Also these diseases kill people with weakened immune systems, and put health people into the hospital, which costs money. German Measles causes pregnant women to have children with severe birth defects. You are 100% wrong with science, as you are with politics.


Read the last sentence.


In theory he is correct. Contracting the illness or getting a vaccine provides immunity. But what you say is also correct. There are too many dangers to justify not getting vaccinated.

hermit thrush

"don't listen to me." finally a john mcelroy comment we can all agree with!

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.