The ink was barely dry on the United States/Mexico/Canada Act when President Donald Trump decided to thumb his nose at one of these international allies.

Mr. Trump made renegotiating the North American Free Trade Agreement a priority of his administration. And what resulted was the USMCA, which took effect July 1. The president heralded the agreement as an achievement in securing better trade terms for the United States.

But on Aug. 6, Mr. Trump announced he would subject Canada to new tariffs on aluminum. The tariffs took effect Sunday, and the Canadian government said it would respond with its own tariffs on U.S. goods containing aluminum.

“Justin Trudeau’s government will hit the U.S. with retaliatory tariffs after President Donald Trump announced plans to impose duties on Canadian aluminum,” according to a Bloomberg News story published Aug. 8 by the Watertown Daily Times. “At a press conference in Ottawa, Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland released a list of more than 60 U.S. aluminum-containing products that could face higher tariffs, but vowed not to escalate the situation beyond what she said was a dollar-for-dollar equivalent duties, totaling C$3.6 billion ($2.7 billion) in goods. She also branded Trump’s administration as the most protectionist in U.S. history.”

U.S. Rep. Elise M. Stefanik, R-Schuylerville, opposed Mr. Trump’s action.

“I oppose the Trump Administration’s decision to reinstate the 10 percent tariffs on imports of non-alloyed aluminum from Canada,” she said in a news release, as reported in the Bloomberg News article. “The United States and Canada have a strong economic partnership and trading relationship. This decision will slow the rate of our economic recovery from COVID-19, particularly for the manufacturers along the Northern border in the north country. Instead, our focus must be on working with our allies to address China’s overcapacity and the subsidized aluminum they continue to dump on the world market. I urge the Administration to reverse this reinstatement so we can focus on restoring our economy while holding unfriendly nations — like China — accountable.”

North Country Chamber of Commerce President Garry Douglas took a similar stance on the tariffs.

“This is an unfortunate act of self-harm by the U.S., as past tariffs against Canada have been,” Mr. Douglas said in the story. “The U.S. and Canada make things together, and this directly increases costs to many of our manufacturers with cross-border supply chains that include aluminum goods. Just weeks ago, on July 1, we implemented the new USMCA agreement as a celebration of the enormous importance of the U.S./Canada economic partnership. And now we are already forgetting the special nature of that partnership. Hopefully, this will be short term in nature and will be reconsidered and reversed quickly.”

Chad P. Brown, an economist and trade analyst the Peterson Institute for International Economics in Washington, was interviewed in a story published Friday in the New York Times. He indicated this move on Mr. Trump’s part doesn’t make a lot of sense.

“Are there big political gains for President Trump heading up to November in picking on Canada? It’s hard to see how that would be,” he said. “If anything, this is a way that he’s differentiating himself from [former] Vice President Biden. Joe Biden has indicated he would work more closely with allies on trade issues.”

Like many of Mr. Trump’s tariffs, this new round will increase costs for raw materials and finished products traded across the Canadian/U.S. border.

What’s good about that? The president should recognize how this measure will hurt trade and sour relations that many have worked to improve and reverse course.

Johnson Newspapers 7.1


Recommended for you

(7) comments


Finally, a President who puts America First. Unlike Slick Willy who gave away it way with the NAFTA fiasco.


Even Stefanik is right on this one. Must’ve gotten a hall pass to speak. She was right on TPP too. Before COVID that was probably Trump’s biggest mistake. So much competition tho. Deaths in the hundreds of thousands is tough to top.


Canadian aluminum was flooding the American market and poised to kill off American jobs. They increased exports to the US by 87% after tariffs were lifted. It’s called America First. What a concept.


Companies like Whirlpool Corp., for example. The appliance manufacturer—which had previously been a cheerleader for Trump's tariffs on imported washing machines—saw its sales and stock prices tumble in the months after Trump's aluminum tariffs took effect, as the import taxes added to the company's input costs. It takes a lot of aluminum to build a washing machine, after all.

That’s from the dirty leftwing hippies at Reason. Canada has a comparative advantage when it comes to making aluminum because they have cheap hydropower. Basic macroeconomics and the principles of free trade are things pre-Trump conservatives used to embrace. It’s whatever Dear Leader says now.


The US aluminum industry collapsed in 2009.. post Bush great recession era... The global financial crisis brought a collapse in aluminum demand as the U.S. automotive industry went into meltdown. Prices slumped and London-traded aluminum hit a low of $1,279 a tonne early in 2009. To rebuild the auto industry they purchased aluminum from China and Canada.. so the "flood" was based on cheaper production costs in Canada/China..and our inability to produce competitively....

So break out your pocketbook Mr. consumer .. the price of cars, beer and anything aluminum just went up..... with a 10%+ unemployment rate.. great timing!




tRUMP's nothing but a fool. MAGA - dump tRUMP

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.