No public body in New York state has yet created a Second Amendment Sanctuary, but residents in two local counties this week urged their elected officials to do so.

About 70 people attended a meeting Monday of the St. Lawrence County Board of Legislators in Canton. And more than 300 residents showed up Tuesday for the meeting of the Lewis County Board of Legislators.

“Becoming a Second Amendment Sanctuary means a locality won’t use law enforcement resources to prosecute the proposed anti-gun laws,” according to a story published Jan. 21 in the Wall Street Journal. “Whether such resolutions have any teeth depends on local officials’ resolve, but at the very least these measures are a reflection of regional sentiment on gun control.”

This idea is based to some extent on the concept of sanctuary cities. Such jurisdictions place limits on their cooperation with authorities striving to enforce federal immigration laws.

Chief among the concerns for gun rights advocates in the north country is the New York Secure Ammunition and Firearms Enforcement Act of 2013. It was rushed through the state Legislature in the middle of the night without advance notice and with little public input.

Patrick Morse of New Bremen, a gun shop owner and National Rifle Association safety trainer, told Lewis County legislators that 52 of the state’s 62 counties passed resolutions opposing the SAFE Act — and each one fell on deaf ears in Albany. It’s easy to understand why state lawmakers often tune out the voices of people from Northern New York.

The Legislature is dominated by Democratic politicians from New York City. They exhibit little knowledge or interest in what those of us from rural parts of the state believe or how we live.

“If we continue to stand idly by while our constitutional rights are being infringed, it will allow these political machines to have domestic domain over the commonwealth of America,” Wyatt Cole of Colton told St. Lawrence County legislators, according to a Watertown Daily Times story published Tuesday. “It will lead to powerful and ambitious politicians to only work for their own profit and personal gain without the unity of the people for their common interests.”

Critics of New York’s gun control measures raise valid points about the flaws in the policymaking process. These ideas may be popular in Manhattan, but they have no appeal here.

Second Amendment Sanctuary ordinances would likely not withstand court challenges. So passing them wouldn’t be wise.

But the growth in the movement is best explained by examining the arrogance of state legislators who have repeatedly ignored people from throughout New York. One-party rule in Albany is eroding trust in state government. And when that party takes its marching orders from its members in one city, the rest of us must conclude that our interests don’t matter.

These politicians believe they know better than anyone else about what’s best for us. They treat us like children who need their pontificating to maintain civility.

Good governance recognizes the rights of all constituents, not just those who keep some officeholders in power. State legislators must reconsider their rationale for passing gun laws. If they don’t acknowledge that residents in rural areas have a stake in how policies are implemented, resistance to their autocratic rule will grow more intense.

Johnson Newspapers 7.1


Recommended for you

(9) comments


Meanwhile, across the land, the shootings continue unabated.


Lewis County - 26,000 people with a declining population. There are 31,000 people who go to college at University of Buffalo. Do you know how many of the 26,000 people who live in Lewis County are on State or Federal aid? Nearly 1 in 5 households gets food stamps. There are excellent reasons Albany doesn't care about Lewis County.


Perhaps they treat you like children because you act and think like a child. Childlike demands, impulse ridden thinking and irresponsible statements confirm this conclusion. The editorial is whining.


Imagine running this editorial the day Trump is acquitted of something he obviously did, then accusing Democrats of anything.

Great meta-comedy WDT editorial staff!


”We want Florida’s gun laws in New York, despite Florida having four times the gun homicide rate as New York”- these men.

Also Republicans- “Gay Marriage is a threat to traditional marriage”.

Republicans are very, very bad at knowing what threats are. The people at David Koresh’s compound in Waco used guns to “stand up to government tyranny” how did that work out for them? (Hint: they watched their kids burn alive horribly in a fire)


Gay marriage, Republicans, Waco, you forgot Trump and the NRA. A little off topic aren’t we?


These guys all say they need guns for protection. Pointing out Republicans are bad at knowing “threats” is on topic.

These guys say they need guns to “stand up to government tyranny”. How has that worked out for gun-lovers in the past?

Sorry you can’t grasp basic recent history. You must be a Trump voter.

Holmes -- the real one

Here's a real threat that the Trump supporters should be concerned about --- poor reading comprehension.


Won't enforce state laws = no state aid.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.