Sheriff, legislators trade barbs

JULIE ABBASS/WATERTOWN DAILY TIMESLewis County Sheriff Michael Carpinelli makes a point at the Board of Legislators meeting Tuesday night.

LOWVILLE — The Lewis County sheriff and legislators agreed on something: things did not go well between them at the regular Board of Legislators meeting on Tuesday evening.

After County Manager Ryan Piche gave a 14-minute presentation showing the Sheriff’s Department budget and spending over the past five years, staffing trends, causes for overtime and the current state of fund availability for the jail, road patrol and recreation patrol, four of the 17 people present not affiliated with the county spoke to the board.

All of the speakers highlighted the importance of the rec patrol, especially the patrol boat on Brantingham Lake, from where the speakers came, but the comments indicated the speakers believe the rec patrol budget was cut.

Sheriff Michael Carpinelli, however, suspended the rec patrol as well as any extra patrols for holidays and special events, in response to being told by the county budget officer, Mr. Piche, that discretionary purchases, starting with a $12,000 purchase of long guns and accessories, would be delayed until the fourth quarter to ensure there was enough money in the overall budget to cover overtime over spending in the department.

“These people are waiting for an answer. They’re waiting for me to put the recreation patrol out there. If I don’t have the funding to do it, I can not do it,” Sheriff Carpinelli said.

Tension mounted as barbs and blame were exchanged between the sheriff and legislators.

Legislators took turns pointing out that the rec patrol budget is still on track and because the majority of its budget is reimbursable, suspending the patrols only hurts the sheriff’s budget and the people of the county.

“Terrible,” Sheriff Carpinelli said on how he felt the confrontation went after leaving the meeting, “No, I’m not compromising. I’ve done that for eight years. They lie about everything.”

Some of the public who attended had a different perspective after the meeting.

“I think from what I’ve seen here the legislators have to get a more detailed breakdown of how the sheriff is spending the budget,” Bob Hindman of Brantingham said.

Legislators said they want to work with the sheriff to solve the problem, but they aren’t optimistic.

“I hope we can work through it, but I don’t see an answer,” said District 2 Legislator Randy LaChausse, “The sheriff knew which hot button to push to get the public in an uproar and that’s just wrong.”

Johnson Newspapers 7.1

Recommended for you

(9) comments

uncle fester

Did the sheriff''s department really hurt the county by not patrolling the trails? Tickets never written anyways.


One again Watertown times censorship? Is Carpinelli on your payroll as well?

Trump's Mini Me

Fake news!! No law enforcement! ATVs rampant and Little Larry and Peachy Piche have hurt feelings.

Trump's Mini Me



It’s amazing how comments disappear when the truth hits a little to close to home?

Trump's Mini Me



Lewis County sheriff dept is in the top ten least professional law enforcement agencies in the entire country. Carpinelli is a joke. He takes a oath to defend the constitution and laws of NYS and he picks and chooses which laws to enforce and who to arrest. He turns a blind eye to several major Pot growers in Lewis county because he probably gets kickbacks?

Trump's Mini Me



Carpinelli is just being his usual a$$.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.